Was Ayisha(ra) age 9 when she married to Rasulullah(sa)?? 🤔
There is differences of opinion about age of ayisha(ra) during her marriage with Rasullah(sa). Some scholars say 14, some say 19 and some say 21. Closest to the truth is age may be 19 or 21. This is the correct opinion. There are historical evidences and also comparing her age with asma(ra) age related ahadith on other books of ahadith . The Hadith narrated by ayisha (ra) whose sanad is sahih but matn i.e text of that Hadith is disputed still as the age might be mistakenly translated to 9 instead of 19.
This hadith cannot be true for several reasons.. First, the Prophet could not have gone against the Quran to marry a physically and intellectually immature child. Secondly, the age of Hazrat Aisha can be easily calculated from the age of her elder sister Hazrat Asma who was 10 years older than Hazrat Aisha. Waliuddin Muhammad Abdullah Al-Khateeb al Amri Tabrizi the famous author of Mishkath, in his biography of narrators (Asma ur Rijal), writes that Hazrat Asma died in the year 73 Hijri at the age of 100, ten or twelve days after the martyrdom of her son Abdullah Ibn Zubair. It is common knowledge that the Islamic calendar starts from the year of the Hijrah or the Prophet’s migration from Mecca to Medina. Therefore, by deducting 73, the year of Hazrat Asma’s death, from 100, her age at that time, we can easily conclude that she was 27 years old during Hijra.This puts the age of Hazrat Aisha at 17 during the same period. As all biographers of the Prophet agree that he consummated his marriage with Hazrat Aisha in the year 2 Hijri it can be conclusively said that she was 19 at that time and not nine as alleged in the aforementioned hadiths.
There are some evidences that she was 21 age from historical sources too. But we certainly say she was not 9. We Muslims must do research with critical thinking instead of blindly believing on Hadith text without analysisng the background. Islam does not agree to this kind of dogmatic attitude.
As per Islam, age of baligh is above 10. Rasul(sa) asked us to strictly discipline children to pray after they attained age 10. For marriage ,consent is important from women. At the age of 6 how a girl can consent ? Let us not be dogmatic. Dogmatism is not in Islam. We don't need to compare age of marriage id Isaac from bible. Islam is rational and rasul(sa) has been sent to whole mankind as rahma as mercy. The time rasul(sa) married to ayisha is "period of extreme worries" of his times. The time where his uncle abutalib , the sole supporter for him, died and time ,his beloved wife Khadija died. Khadija ral sister recommended rasul(sa) to get married and recommneded ayisha. How can a girl of 6 give consolence to rasul(sa) at this critical period of his life? We have to think much.
Scholarly world must do research to this. Whatver I said earlier is not my opinion. This was some of the classical scholars opinion and they say this with sound text.
We don't need to justify of having comparing with the age of 3 marriage to Issac. That's idiotic. We can say bible is not right by saying this. But by showing this biblical notation to justify ayisha age of marriage with rasul(say) is not correct. Whatever quotations I quoted before are from tabieens period of scholars. Bukhari has some Hadith which dishonors rasul(sa). Probably due to texual mistakes. Bukhari manuscript compiled after 100 years of imam bukhari's demise by his student's students. This is historical fact. Texual mistakes obviously occur. Let us be realistic. Even Hadith experts who has given commentary to bukhari kitab themselves agree to this. Ibn hajar says more than 70 Hadith disputed.. some say 100 and some say 200. In our period some scholars say all Hadith in bukhari are sahih. Sanad may be sahiu but texts of some Hadith disputed. I can list more than 50 Hadith whose texts are disputed.
There are many cases four imams of high calibre rejected certain sahih sanad narrations too when they find disputed texts. Hadith may be sound bil isnad.. but bil matn some Hadiths (may be close 100 in bukhari) still gives confusing understandings and against Quranic teachings. Let us be honest.
There are list of issues where some expert western Muslim scholars clarifying us by valid evidences. Historically speaking during Banu Umayyad period , many hypocrites try to demonize rasul(sa) family members including Ali, Abu talib , Hassan husssain and rasul's parents..etc. before rasul(sa) attain prophet hood, political clash was between Banu uammayah and Banu Hashim. After his(sa) demise, after sound pure rulership of Islam of 30 years or 40 years, years of tyranny started..again Banu ummayad and Banu Abbas political clash started. we have to understand those were the period of tyranny in Islamic history after hijri 40 or 50. false Hadith spread like swarms at that time.many in clergy support monarchs of that time out of fear except ffew. Many false ahadirh spread by Banu ummayad during yazid period and after him also. One among this issue is age of ayisha. At that time this was not disputed as marriage was acceptaklble once girl attain puberty. But question is do rasulullah(sa) do such marriage.? He never did. He is rahmath lil aalameen. He is unique and has been sent as mercy until end of times.
Most of the Hadith saying ayisha(ral)'s age is 9 at the time of her marriage is by Hisham ibn urwa who narrates this from Iraq. His reports were not relied upon after he moved to Iraq. Imam Malik , madinan Donn, kept him unreliable list after Hisham moved to Iraq. That's why we cant see ayisha's age related Hadith in Malik muwatta. Moreover the age related matter was pivotely need of that jurisprudential times and it is not that imam Malik not aware of this Hadith. The reason is his manhaj is preferring traditions of medina over others.There were no related Hadith spread in Medina at his times pertains to ayisha's age at the time of her marriage to rasul(sa).. imam dhahabi(rah) too not taken certain narrations of Hisham saying he declined memory due to his old age.Wallahu 'alam.
Hisham ibn urwa lived in Madina for 71 years and he did not narrate this during this times.but after 71 years he moved to Iraq where news of this age related Hadith spread saying this coming from narrations of Hisham ibn urwah..questions usually arise how it was not narrated before.
Hadiths mentioned about age allowed for battle of uhud as 14. It is said in Hadith in bukhari that ayisha(Ra) participated in this battle which is on 4 AH. So if that is the case that ayisha(Ra) was 9 yrs at the time of her marriage with rasul(sa) which happent on 2 A H, then her age at the time of uhud battle was 11.serving warriors carrying heavy weight water jug for them on this age is not apt. Moreover how did she participate when age limit was 14 for uhud?
One more evidence, ayisha (Ra) saying she was jariyah (young girl) at the time of revelation of surah kaaf surah number 54. This Hadith also coming in bukhari.
This was revealed 9 years before hijrah means ,then her age was not 9 at the time of her marriage.
Imam tabari says that all four children of abubacker(Ra) born at the time of jahiliyyah. If this is the case, during ayisha's marriage time, she attained age more than 14. Some reports say ayisha (Ra) born before 4 years of first revelation and some say after 4 years of after first revelation. After revelations report might not be true due to other supportive evidences..
Ibn Hisham says that ayisha (Ra) accepted islam before Umar(Ra). Umar(Ra) accepted islam during first one or second year of Islam. If this is the case, then first year of Islam ,she was mature enough to know what is right and what is wrong.
Ahmed Ibn hanbal(rah) says khadija's sister recommended rasul(sa) marrying bikr(virgin). She meant ayisha. Bikr is word used for more mature women I.e unmarried lady. This word not used for 9 year old girl in Arabic language.
Few more evidences are..
There were no sound reports in any Hadith books saying any of the sahabahs marrying girl of age below 10. So this was not the tradition of of Arabs at that time marrying child of age 9.
There was no such tradition of marrying 9 aged women by sahabahs at that time and not only sahabahs , even among kufffaars at that Time in whole arabia. There were no any authentic hadith or any historical records for it. If rasul(sa) married 9 years old girl, that itself gave sign for kuffar to mock at him(sa). We see no such mocking happent against rasul(sa) in any ahadith or historical records..
Present day scholars must unveil these open secrets to the public and enlighten their minds on this. The reason they cling to this belief is the Hadith that mentions her age was 9 in sahih bukhari is narrated by Aisha(ra) herself. The Hadith is very sound authentic as per sanad. That's the crux here. They fearing that if they do critically analyse, that may affect backend usool of hadith. But it is not so. Usul al Hadith will not get affected as the critical analysis on this hadith has other clear evidences. That's the matter here.
There are other dogmatic opinions similar like ayisha age was 9 when she married , make younger generation in western world leaving islam. I am saying from sound proofs.there are many videos and articles written by these youths. It is there in whole social media. Some Western scholars also exhibit these truths*. Today's younger generation is expecting reason for all and they don't like taking dogmatic stand like early muslims do. These youths are expecting reasons. Allah(swt) also asked us to think and seek answers with reasons.. islam is not against reasons. Islam is encouraging asking reasons.. many dogmatic beliefs there within sunni and shia community and those must be clarified. Otherwise we lose islam from young generations in west and east.
There is no dogmatism in Islam. When reasons and evidences from Quran and sunnah holds different, sticking blindly without analysis on opinion saying this hadith of aisha age was 9 at the time of her marriage and hadith is sahih was narrated by aisha(ra) herself is what dogmatism is.
May Allah clarify us from messages that dishonors rasul(sa). Aameen.
Comments
Post a Comment