The Legacy of Ibn Abd al-Wahhab and the Heavy Cost of Takfir


   I happened to see a video of Salih al-Fawzan, in which he attempts to defend the historical stance of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab regarding the practice of takfir, the act of declaring ignorant Muslims (those who call upon awliya, asking dua in front of Graves, slaughtering other than Allah etc) as kafir or kuffar (disbelievers). It is important to look at this topic with a clear, calm heart, especially for everyday Muslims who want to understand the truth of our faith. Here is a simple look at why we must be extremely careful with these labels.

   If you read the Qur'an carefully, you will notice something beautiful. When Allah speaks to humanity, He uses words like "O mankind" or "O people." He is inviting everyone toward the truth. Despite the fact that there were many polytheists in Arabia at the time, you will not find the phrase "O you polytheists" (yaa ayyuhal mushrikoon) used as a direct address to them in the Qur'an. Most of the people were simply ignorant of the truth, and for this reason, they were addressed as "O people" (yaa ayyuhannaas). Even when the Qur'an uses harsh labels like kafir or mushrik, it is almost never used to address the common people directly. When the phrase "O you disbelievers" (yaa ayyuhal kaafiroon) appears, it is a command for the Prophet (sa) to say it to the specific leaders of that time, the elites who were power hungry and actively working to turn people away from Allah to keep their own status. These were not ignorant people; they were powerful figures who knowingly fought against the truth.

   If Allah, the All Knowing, chose not to address the masses with these labels, how can we be so quick to use them against our own brothers and sisters today? A person who has accepted Allah and His Messenger (sa) is a Muslim. Even if they have faults, or if some of their practices are incorrect, the solution is not to cast them out of the fold of Islam.

   Instead of declaring them kuffar, we should focus on correcting their misunderstandings through wisdom and patience. Declaring someone a kafir is not a light matter; it is something we should be "extremely, extremely careful" about. We cannot talk about the history of the movement started by Ibn Abd al-Wahhab without acknowledging the reality of what happened. When he aligned with the House of Saud, the practice of calling other Muslims kuffar was used to gain political power.

   History shows us that this led to terrible destruction, with many innocent Muslims killed by those who used this ideology to justify their actions. When we look at scholars in Saudi Arabia today, they are in an extremely difficult situation. If they were to speak openly about the fanatic, harmful stands taken in the past, they would likely be jailed or imprisoned by the ruling family, who rely on that history for their own power.It takes immense guts and spirit to strive for the truth regardless of the risks involved. That kind of courage is not easy to attain. Given the current reality in Saudi Arabia, many scholars live in genuine fear; speaking the truth about these historical events is simply too dangerous for them.

   True scholars should have the courage to speak truth to power, but we must acknowledge that the current situation makes this incredibly difficult for many. As regular Muslims, we must realize that labels like kafir are not tools to be used for political gain or to attack those we disagree with. Our faith is built on mercy and guidance. Let us move away from the habit of judging the faith of others and focus on the character and kindness that the Prophet (sa) taught us to have toward every human being.


Comments